Thursday, September 17, 2026

Who Knows, Whose Nose, Needs Mohs*

 


Setting of House Call

 

I retired from my dermatology practice ~ six months ago. 

A few days ago, T.G.,  an old patient, called me regarding his visit with his new dermatologist who practices in our area. She is a “Mohs” surgeon, but not  Fellowship trained being a member of the American Society of Mohs Surgeons (https://www.mohssurgery.org/). She found a basal cell carcinoma on his nose. The patient is a worrier and he, nor his wife) had ever even noticed this lesion. A biopsy showed basal cell carcinoma, so she brought him in for surgery. He is a 75-year-old man in excellent health (I have known him for almost 20 years), although he does have significant health anxiety. The “Mohs’ surgeon did not give him options such as radiotherapy, which is closer to his home. Instead, she brought him in for Mohs. It took three stages and he wound up with a graft from near his left ear. It’s clear that this may have been over-treatment. I asked him to get the path reports for me. The point here is overuse of Mohs surgery in the United States. We have over 2400 Mohs surgeons. Canada has around 30. About half of the Mohs surgeons in the US are not Fellowship trained. Doug Johnson and I have been trying to research this. The question is how to protect patients from venal Mohs surgeons and educate them better. Of course, I need to make sure that this patient did not have an infiltrative basal cell. If that was so micrographic surgery was appropriate, but the fellowship trained Mohs surgeons did not have the background to do it properly. 

Two days later I drove up to Vermont to do a house call on T.G.. He had a copy of the path report which  showed that a shave biopsy showed a small modular basal cell carcinoma on the left ala nasi. The dermatologist made a follow up appointment for micrographic surgery. The lesion was tiny, less than 6 mm in diameter. He was given no other options such as observation, imiquimod or radiotherapy. The dermatologist is not fellowship trained, but is a member of the American Society for Micrographic Surgery. I checked the wound (Figure 1).


It appears that the tumor was a small lesion and is now covered with a bolster. While I think this therapy is appropriate, it also could be excessive. My main criticism is that he was not given any options. He lives about 2 miles from a hospital that has good radiotherapy. The micrographic surgeon is about 30 miles from his home. In my opinion, there are obvious problems with Mohs surgeons who do not have the appropriate training, but can legally call themselves Mohs surgeons. 

While I was at the patient’s house, he asked if I would mind seeing his son. His son who is about 50 years old has no medical insurance.  Shortly thereafter, he came over the house. He has what appears to be an ulcerative basal cell carcinoma on the left lower lid (Figure 2). 

Ironically, this lesion would be appropriate for micrographic surgery, but it require a diagnostic biopsy. Getting treatment for a lesion such as this which would require micrographic surgery and possibly oculoplastic repair or radiotherapy (although he is on the young side).  Both would be expensive propositions for a patient without insurance.

* Who knows/ whose nose/ needs Mohs. is a poem written by E. Dorinda Shelly

Wednesday, September 2, 2026

Dr. Paul S. Russell, Obituary

 Dr. Paul S. Russell, who was born before the discovery of penicillin and who became a leading transplant surgeon, adapting scientific breakthroughs in the laboratory to help make the miracle of a new kidney or liver a relatively common procedure, died on Aug. 22 at his home in Westwood, Mass. He was 101.

His long tenure at Massachusetts General led to vast improvements at the hospital in organ transplant care. In the late 1960s, he also created an organ bank to match donors to recipients.

If you can't access the NY Times Obit, and want to read the full article, please email DJ Elpern and I'll send you a link. 

Image from MGH Archives


Friday, August 28, 2026

In Memoriam: Dr. Alfred W. Kopf

Note: This is a Preprint.  It has not yet been peer reviewed by a journal.

 

A Fortunate Man: Remembering Dr. Alfred W. Kopf

Katherine Bai, David J. Elpern MD, D. Tucker Slingerland MD
KB Williams College, Williamstown, MA
DJE The Skin Clinic, Williamstown, MA
DTS The Hudson Headwaters Health Network, West Glen Falls, NY

D. Tucker Slingerland, MD: On a cold February morning in 2010, Al and Dottie Kopf appeared
on my schedule as new patients. Having relocated to the Adirondack Region of New York State,
I was surprised to learn that Al had researched and selected me as their new primary care
provider. Al wore a jacket and tie and came well prepared. From his briefcase, he shared their
concise medical histories, including medications and detailed daily records of their blood
pressure and heart rate. This became the standard over many years of follow-up appointments.
I clearly remember how excited he became when I showed him my dermatoscope, gifted to
me by David Elpern many years earlier when I was a medical student. On subsequent visits, Al
gave me a small library of books that he had authored. At every visit, before I could ask about
them, Al and Dottie wanted to know about my family and kids. He continued to read medical
journals and add to his vast knowledge of dermatology well into his late nineties, often bringing
me articles. But what impressed me most was his sincere interest in the lives of others, which is
what I am certain made him such a beloved physician and colleague.
Many years later, as I watched Al listen to his last case presentation, I knew that his
incredibly rich life was nearing the end. His lips had a tint of blue, and talking long sentences
was increasingly uncomfortable for him; but he leaned in and listened closely to the Williams
College student and did not miss a single teaching point. The energy of the interaction between
teacher and student, with an audience consisting of family and a physician he helped train
decades earlier in the background could have just as easily occurred during teaching rounds at
NYU Skin and Cancer.

D. Tucker Slingerland and Dr. Kopf, July 2025

David J. Elpern, MD: Last fall, we drove to Lake George, N.Y. from Williamstown, Massachusetts
to visit the eminent dermatologist, Dr. Al Kopf, who I first studied under in 1968 as a third-year
medical student at NYU School of Medicine. Even then, he was a highly regarded dermatologist,
one of the world’s experts on skin cancer. I remember him wearing a long white coat and sober
tie and being in constant motion, trailed by attentive medical students, residents, and fellows.
Five decades passed. Kopf was one of the earliest adopters of the dermatoscope .1 PubMed lists
351 articles authored or co-authored by “Kopf AW.” On that colorful October day, at 99, he and
Dottie, his wife of 75 years lived a quiet life on the idyllic shores of Lake George, NY. I visited
him at the invitation of Tucker Slingerland, his family doctor, who I have known since he was a
freshman at Williams College in 1994 and Katherine Bai, a current Williams student who hopes
to become a dermatologist. Dylan Thomas wrote that we “should not go gentle into that good
night,” 2 but someone like Dr. Kopf has accomplished so much and fought so many battles over
the years that he will likely go gentle into that good night with, apparently no, or few, regrets.
On our visit, Katherine gave her first case presentation. She had been in my office the day
before when we saw an 85-year-old retired surgeon who was concerned about a new
pigmented lesion on his right knee. Clinically and dermatoscopically it was worrisome, so we
excised it in my office (Figure 2). Katherine relayed this case, her first clinical presentation, to
Dr. Kopf, an awe-inspiring master dermatologist. Here was a woman more than 75 years his
junior, who plans to enter his medical specialty, presenting a patient with a possible melanoma
to the man who helped introduce dermatoscopy to the United States, 33 years ago. 1

Katherine Bai,
Williams College BA ‘26: On a sunny October Friday in 2025, I had the honor of
meeting with, and giving my first case presentation to, the late Dr. Alfred Kopf, a pioneering
dermatologist whose work helped to transform the field of dermatology. He was instrumental
in revolutionizing the diagnosis and treatment of melanoma in the United States through his
advancement of the dermatoscope. This is a legacy that continues to shape modern
dermatologic practice and patient care today.
During my presentation, I discussed the office visit in Williamstown, MA of an 85-year-old
retired surgeon who had noticed a new pigmented lesion on his right knee and what we documented with dermatoscopy. 

Photo taken by Makayla Powers, PA-C
 This experience demonstrated the lasting impact of Dr. Kopf’s contributions on both physicians and patients alike. Even at 99, and well beyond his retirement, Dr. Kopf remained deeply engaged with the case I presented. His eyes lit up as we discussed the details; his mouth crinkled into a warm smile. Dr. Kopf’s clarity and intellectual curiosity were unmistakable. He probed the dermatoscopic image thoughtfully, explaining the areas that stood out to me. His attentiveness reflected not only his brilliance but also his lifelong passion for teaching and mentorship.
Dr. Kopf seemed deeply moved to see how his work had been carried forward by subsequent
generations of physicians. His dedication to patient care and commitment to expanding access
through the development of global clinics 3 and innovative diagnostic approaches radically
improved the quality of dermatologic care both nationally and internationally.
After discussing the case, I was struck by the “intergenerational nature” of the moment: a
retired dermatologist renowned in his field, his former student from NYU School of Medicine
(now a practicing dermatologist), his dedicated primary care provider, Dr. Tucker Slingerland,
and myself, a graduating college student just beginning her medical journey. Witnessing this
continuity of learning and commitment to patient care gave me hope for the future of medicine. To encounter someone of such distinction at an early stage in my life was formative and inspiring. This rare opportunity to learn from and engage with Dr. Kopf remains a cherished experience for me.

References:
1. Yadav S, Vossaert KA, Kopf AW, Silverman M, Grin. Histopathologic correlates of
structures seen on dermoscopy (epiluminescence microscopy). Am J Dermatopathol.
1993 Aug;15(4):297-305. doi: 10.1097/00000372-199308000-00001.
2. Thomas D. Do Not Go Gentle into That Good Night. Poets.org. 1971.
https://poets.org/poem/do-not-go-gentle-good-night.
3. Kopf AW. International Foundation for Dermatology: A challenge to meet the
dermatologic needs of developing countries. Dermatol Clin. 1993 Apr;11(2):311-4.


Saturday, August 15, 2026

Dermatologists Near Williamstown, Massachusetts

 Dermatologists in the Williamstown Area

 

Presently, these are the dermatology providers in or around Berkshire County 

If you want your records sent to a new provider, please go to:
Medical Records Custodian
 

 

Victoria Cavalli, M.D.

77 Hospital Ave #200,
North Adams, MA 01247

website: healthyskinsite,com

Lixia Ellis, M.D.

140 Hospital Dr,
Bennington, VT 05201

https://providers.dartmouth-health.org/209/lixia-z-ellis

Scott Goffin, D.O.

17 Taconic Ave,
Great Barrington, MA 01230

413-528-5184

 

Lisa Hochman, M.D. (part time)

Berkshire Dermatology & Plastic Surgery

55 Pittsfield Road, Building 12C

Lenox, MA 01240

https://www.berkshirehealthsystems.org/provider/lisa-hochman/




John Kwon, M.D.

Berkshire Dermatology & Plastic Surgery

55 Pittsfield Road, Building 12C

Lenox, MA 01240

https://www.berkshirehealthsystems.org/provider/john-kwon/

 

It may be easier to get an appointment at the following offices.

Hudson Dermatology

98 Green St Ste. 4,
Hudson, NY 12534, USA

(518) 412-3300

https://hudsondermatology.com/

 

Skin Specialists of the Capital Region

1. 264 Washington Avenue Ext. Suite 201 

Albany, NY 12203   |   (518) 452-1928

2. 2 Executive Park Drive, 2nd Floor

Albany, NY 12203     |   (518) 452-1928

https://skinspecialistscr.com/


Kavita Menon, MD and Virginia Tracey, MD

Magnolia Dermatology

582 Loudon Rd, Latham, NY 12110

518-875-3376


Katherine L. White, M.D., F.A.A.D.
Hampshire Dermatology

39A Carlon Drive

Northampton, MA 01060

(413) 585-0010


Joseph Schwartz

137 Hoosick Street

Troy, NY 12180

(518) 274-4305


Rebecca Jones, M.D.

Whately Health Center

181 State Road/route 5&10

Whately MA 01093 (her main office is in Brattleboro, VT)

Tuesday 8:30 a.m. – 3 p.m.

413-397-8919


 

There are also dermatologists in Saratoga, NY,, Amherst and Springfield, MA.

 

If you want your records sent to a new provider, please go to: Medical Records Custodian 



Friday, August 7, 2026

Resources

 Over the years, I have used some online websites that can be of help to peoplke with skin disease.  The best is:

Dermnet  Is open to the public. and is user-friendly.

DermNet® is the world’s leading free dermatology resource. It was launched in 1996, by Dr. Amanda Oakley, under the umbrella of the New Zealand Dermatological Society, and as of 2017, around 2 million people access the website monthly.

While DermNet® is created for healthcare professionals to serve as a comprehensive database of skin conditions, I have found that it is user-friendly for membersof the public with skin problems.

Nearly everyone will experience a skin issue at some point in their lives and having a trustworthy, independent, easily accessible source of information is important for both practitioner and patient. DermNet® is that resource. Trustworthy, forever free, and accessible to anyone at any time.



PubMed is an openly accessible, free database which primarily includes the MEDLINE database of references and abstracts on life sciences and biomedical topics. The United States National Library of Medicine (NLM) at the National Institutes of Health maintains the database.

From 1971 to 1997, online access to the MEDLINE database was provided via computer, using phone lines primarily through institutional facilities, such as university libraries. PubMed, first released in January 1996, ushered in the era of private, free, home and office-based MEDLINE searching. The PubMed system was offered free to the public starting in June 1997.

Thursday, August 6, 2026

Medical Records Custodian

Your medical records are being stored at Morgan Records Management.

Morgan is a company that is licensed to handle and store private healthcare records so that they can be accessible when you need them. They comply with all Massachusetts guidelines for retention of medical records. You can contact Morgan Records Management (MRM) to get physical or electronic copies delivered to you or a new provider at this link. It can take up to 30 days from the date of your request to receive your records.  If biopsies were done, you can get the results from the lab we used in a few days.  See below.  Your chart at MRM will also have your Patr reports.

If you want to know more about requesting your records, go to this link: MRM.  Morgan charges a fee to retrieve your records. Additionally, it was costly for me to store them there.  However, they provide the security that your records need to be safe and retrievable.

 

Biopsy Results.  Most of our biopsies were sent to Berkshire Medical Center.  In that case your pathology results will be on your Portal.  You can also request path results from Berkshire Medical Center at this Web Page.  

Reflections

After over 50 years as a dermatologist, I have finally retired.  The emotions are bitter-sweet.  Yet as Kenny Rogers sang in The Gambler:

"If you're gonna play the game, boyYou gotta learn to play it right
 
You've got to know when to hold 'emKnow when to fold 'emKnow when to walk awayAnd know when to runYou never count your moneyWhen you're sittin' at the tableThere'll be time enough for countin'When the dealin's done

or, better yer\t, as the final couplet of Shakespeare's Sonnet. # 73 proclaims:

This thou perceiv'st, which makes thy love more strong,
To love that well which thou must leave ere long.
 
It's time to fold them and I do so with love for my profession after many decades in the Skin Trade.
 

 

 

Between a Rock and a Hard Place

The patient is a 53-year-old man with a two-year history of lesion on the left lower lid. He had a basal cell carcinoma of the left ala that...